| Year | Runner | Class |
| 2002 | Todd Smalling | Freshman |
| 2000 | Shane Byrne | Junior |
| 1999 | Shane Byrne | Sophomore |
| 1998 | Shane Byrne | Freshman |
| 1997 | John Goodwin | Senior |
| 1982 | Walter Deneen | Senior |
| 1981 | Walter Deneen | Junior |
| 1970 | Mark Brown | Senior |
| 1965 | David Huff | Junior |
| 1964 | David Huff | Sophomore |
| 1963 | Dan Clark | Senior |